How to Sign "Instead"
To sign "instead," form "F" handshapes with both hands by touching the tips of your index fingers and thumbs together while keeping your other fingers extended. Hold both hands in front of your body, with your non-dominant hand slightly further out. Move your dominant hand forward in a slight arc over your non-dominant hand while simultaneously pulling your non-dominant hand closer to your body, effectively swapping their positions.
Visual Logic(Etymology)
The sign for "instead" is highly iconic, meaning its physical movement directly mirrors its meaning. It visually represents the concept of exchanging, swapping, or replacing one thing with another. By having your two hands physically trade places in space, you are painting a clear picture of taking an original idea or object and putting a new one in its spot. This visual logic makes the sign very intuitive to remember.
Signing Tips
Focus on the smooth, circular swapping motion of your hands. The "F" handshapes should remain consistent throughout the movement, with the tips of your index fingers and thumbs touching. Think of the motion as physically taking one item and replacing it with another. This visualization helps make the sign look natural and fluid. Make sure the movement is distinct but not overly exaggerated.
Common Mistakes
A common mistake beginners make is only moving their dominant hand while keeping the non-dominant hand completely still. Remember that both hands should move simultaneously to swap places, creating a true exchange. Another frequent error is using closed fists or "O" handshapes instead of the crisp "F" handshape. Keep those middle, ring, and pinky fingers extended to ensure the sign is clear and easily understood.
Regional Variations
This sign is widely used and understood across the ASL community with minimal regional variation.
Examples Using "Instead" in a Sentence
1I want water instead of soda.
Sign "water," then use the sign for "instead," followed by "soda." The physical swapping motion of the hands perfectly emphasizes the replacement of one drink choice with another.
2Let's go tomorrow instead.
Sign "go" and "tomorrow," then finish the sentence with "instead" to show you are swapping your current plan for a brand new one.
3Can I have an apple instead?
Sign "apple," then "instead," making sure to use raised eyebrows at the end of the sentence to indicate that you are asking a yes/no question.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the sign for "instead" the same as "trade"?
Yes, the sign for "instead" is the exact same sign used for words like "trade," "exchange," or "replace." The context of your sentence will make it clear to the person you are signing with which English concept you mean.
Does it matter which hand moves forward?
Yes, typically your dominant hand starts closer to your body and moves forward, while your non-dominant hand starts slightly further out and moves backward toward you. This creates a natural, comfortable swapping motion.
Can I use this sign for "substitute"?
Absolutely! Since the sign visually represents swapping one thing for another, it works perfectly for concepts like "substitute," "replace," or "instead." It is a very versatile sign for any situation involving an exchange.
Related ASL Signs